I tested a ton of clean mascaras, and these are the 6 best ones

April 2020

Shop Phyto-Pigments Ultra-Natural Mascara

“This mascara enhances your color without making it look too dark, your volume without venturing into over-the-top territory, and your length without leaving tiny clumps at the end of your lashes. My lashes felt extremely hydrated, and I liked that the mascara made them look like a better, more slicked version of themselves—without any irritation.”